Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jenny Logan's avatar

I once heard someone describe secular meditation as emptying oneself out, but prayer to the on true God is an act of filling yourself up—pouring the Holy Spirit into your empty places. I rather liked that explanation. I too did the meditation thing before becoming a Christian, and now I pray every day. Like you say, not sure if I’m doing it right, but I’m doing it—and I find as I talk to God I get answers.

Etienne de Rivoli's avatar

Thank-you for posting this.

I always look forward to reading your posts.

That having been said, and not wanting to be contradictory or pedantic, I feel compelled to make a couple notes, to writ:

* According to the spiritual teachings of St John of The Cross, St Teresa of Avila, Garrigou LaGrange, Johann Tayler, and Aquinas, Saurez, Billot, Marcel Lefebvre et Al, meditation is, in fact, a form of prayer. The Ignatian meditations exemplify poignantly that in meditation, one is active rather than passive.

* Contemplation, on the contrary, highest form of prayer, is passive rather than active.

* It is the false meditation style of the Buddhists that says we must empty ourselves, thinking of nothing.

Contrarywise, in Christian meditation, the mind is active and the antitheses of emptying ourselves.

* That having been said, there is, indeed, a place for the Eastern model of meditation:

Focusing on breathing, practicing being in the moment, etc (especially for those with any anxiety issues, among other variables.

* I heartily recommend, and cannot recommend enough, the work

"Achieving Peace of Heart" by Narciso Orals, S.J., published by Abbey Press.

Don't be deceived by the title -- It is a vademecum for re-educating the Will, the intellect, the emotional apparatus, and provides the best methods of relaxation, breathing exercises, and all the best the Eastern models of meditation can provide.and uses the most Catholic and Thomist methods of classical Swiss psychoanalysis tools that have proved extraordinarily more effective than the Freudian model, with a neglible ratio of attrition that typifies Freudian and pop culture methods of therapy (such as A.A., with an over 90 % attrition rate!).

* Please correct me if I've misunderstood your post, as I haven't yet had my morning coffee.

+ Pax, frater!.+

21 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?