Discussion about this post

User's avatar
J. H. Guy's avatar

I don't think you exaggerated at all; you hit the nail on the head. I began to realize this a few yeara ago, sometime after a reconversion as well. Finally ejected "The Office" from my canon of culture, which I actually consider to have good character work and decent comedy.

To explore one of your points more, a sitcom psychologically acts like family time in the evening. We are watching and emoting with a group of people who do not exist, and have no intended end, only when they lose funding for the show.

This is different than a show like Breaking Bad (which I certainly have qualms with now as a faithful Catholic and haven't watched it since). But Breakimg Bad functions more like a Brothers Karamazov, it has an intended ending and it has something to say. In that sense it is actually art, whereas the Office, Friends, Parks and Rec, How I Met Your Mother, are all placeholders for a family and and a mental medication for social conditioning.

Mike Praus's avatar

I really think it is a matter of perspective. When i watch friends i watch it to have a fun time watching people who behave like kids struggle to get their life together despite irony, bad luck, etc.

At no point am i trying to become like them.

The whole piece stems on the idea that you will imitate what you consume. But that is not true. You are affected by what you consume and it is about the perspective in which you are consuming that dictates the emotions and actions that follow.

If it were as simple as imitate what you consume then all detectives would be murderers. Consuming can definitely lower your sensitivity to such things and make you more likely to do such things, but it isn’t as cut and dry as the article makes it seem.

I think the premise of this article as a consequence calls for a society that hides itself from anything that isn’t rainbows, when in reality we are called to combat darkness and we’ll need to study it to do so.

Overall, I think the article touches on something real but mistakes the solution for total abstinence instead of perspective change or the state of your heart.

526 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?